Painters succeed while rejecting art culture of the time
BY MICHAEL SWAN
The Catholic Register
Sunday Morning No. 2 by Jack Chambers
Self Portrait by William Kurelek
Images courtesty of John and Diego Chambers and teh Thomson Collection, Art Gallery of Ontario.
Caption: Auther Herman Goodden reveals the unusual true stories about three Canadian painters in a new book called, Three Artists: Kurelek, Chambers & Curnoe.
But if you think books about art and artists are dull, academic, jargon-laden wastes of time, paper and ink, Goodden wants you to think again.
In his new book about three important 20th-century Canadian painters, Goodden does his best to include all the weirdness he could dig up about William Kurelek, Jack Chambers and Greg Curnoe. But it’s not weird for weirdness’ sake. Goodden wants to tell stories — stories that give you a concrete sense of the lives of his three artists.
There’s the story about how Chambers in 1954 used a pound of sausage to distract Pablo Picasso’s guard dogs, then invaded the house of the most famous artist in the world so he could ask for advice about where he should attend art school. Having accomplished this, Chambers ignored Picasso’s advice and caught the next train out of town.
Curnoe stayed three years at the Ontario College of Art in Toronto resolutely flunking courses and insisting that his old high school art program at H.B. Beal Secondary School in London, Ont., was far superior.
But Curnoe and Chambers were not really crazy. In fact, Goodden finds himself impressed by Curnoe’s upright, hardworking artist’s ethic.
“Curnoe was utterly faithful to his first and only wife Sheila, was emotionally and practically very present in the raising of their three children,” Goodden writes in Three Artists: Kurelek, Chambers and Curnoe released in November by Elmwood Publications.
Curnoe was “refreshingly un-eccentric and un-self-preoccupied, and for all the unorthodoxy of his calling as an artist and the originality of his vision, Curnoe displayed a sober and hard-working diligence that would’ve paid equally big dividends in hardware store management or accounting.”
The book was commissioned by the Catholic Art Guild of London, Ont., to tell the stories of these three artists, their lives of faith and their search for meaning.
In William Kurelek, easily Canada’s most popular painter from the 1960s through the 1980s, Goodden has tales to tell of real madness — not eccentricity, but crushing, debilitating mental illness.
In 1952 a depressed and traumatized Kurelek knew he was losing his sanity. He became fascinated with experiments in art therapy undertaken at England’s Netherne Hospital. He wrote to ask whether he could be treated there.
Hospital administrators replied that Canada was somewhat out of their catchment area. So Kurelek moved to England. He arrived June 1, 1952, and was admitted to London’s Maudsley Hospital (sister institution to the Netherne) on June 4.
Kurelek spent the better part of a decade in and out of the Maudsley and Netherne Hospitals.
While at Maudsley, Kurelek was thoroughly frustrated and disappointed by his course of treatment. He was about to become the only Canadian artist whose sanity was saved by a Catholic newspaper. The Catholic newspaper’s role in saving Kurelek was minor, but crucial.
During his treatment his one ray of light was an occupational therapist named Margaret Smith. Smith and Kurelek would talk about all sorts of things and the talk left the 25-year-old artist, atheist and socialist feeling less estranged from the world. Among their mutual interests was poetry. When Smith gave Kurelek a book of poems wrapped (for protection) in a Catholic newspaper, Kurelek was confronted with the idea that the one person he could talk to actually believed in everything he had rejected.
Smith never tried to convert him or even explain her faith to the young artist. When Kurelek asked Smith whether she was praying for him, she said yes. It was just there, a fact Kurelek had to deal with — the person who understood him best, whom he could speak to most easily, actually prayed, believed in God and accepted the authority of the Church.
Kurelek didn’t just become Catholic. He became the sort of Catholic the art world could not abide. Open and up front about his religious convictions, much of Kurelek’s output was explicitly religious in a way that was unimaginable for a generation of artists who hid their spirituality behind gestures in paint and high concepts in psychology and philosophy. In the age of minimalism, Kurelek was using paintings to tell stories, publishing his work in book form — A Northern Nativity, Kurelek’s Canada, A Prairie Boy’s Winter.
Goodden recounts how the art community reacted to Kurelek.
“Probably the most damning instance of the complete disregard for Kurelek and what he was trying to do was by Dennis Reid in, I think it was about ’73 or so, a few years before Kurelek dies (1977),” Goodden told The Catholic Register. “(He) comes out with A Concise History of Canadian Painting published by Oxford University Press. Kurelek is then at his peak. He does not get mentioned. William Kurelek does not exist, according to this Concise History.
“Then (Reid) revamped it in the ’80s (second edition, 1988), years after Kurelek had died. And he worked in three paragraphs. Among those three paragraphs was ‘At the time of his death, William Kurelek was the most popular artist in the country.’”
It might have been nice if the art world had been willing to acknowledge Kurelek’s accomplishment while the artist was still alive, said Goodden.
In the end, Goodden finds himself with stories of three men who were outsiders — whether by choice or by circumstance.
Jack Chambers took umbrage when the National Gallery of Canada in 1967 thought he would be so honoured to have his paintings included in a package of educational materials the gallery provided to schools that he wouldn’t want actual payment for his work. He fought back by writing to over 100 artists across the country and forming Canadian Artists Representation to demand that artists be paid for their work. The National Gallery from that point forward did not show any Chambers paintings or collect any of his work during his lifetime.
Greg Curnoe spent his life sneering at the New York art scene and Americans in general. And he had unkind words to say about Toronto when the city seemed to present itself as another New York.
“He was the guy who proved, if you put your foot down, you don’t have to go to New York. You don’t have to go to Toronto. You don’t have to suck up to anyone.”
Art was Curnoe’s means of kicking back at every kind of authority — the authority of the art market, the authority of American culture, the authority of academic experts.