Celibacy is not to blame for pedophilia
No, it is not fair to blame celibacy for the crime of pedophilia
committed by some priests and bishops. It is as wrong to say this as it is
to say that marriage causes adultery, red lights traffic violations, or drug
stores substance abuse.
I was shocked by the media proposal that the Catholic Church should
review her policy on celibacy, suggesting that it be abolished.
The recent scandal in North America has brought shame and deep anguish to
all priests because some people may think that all of us are guilty of this
I begin this series of articles not only with tears of sorrow and shame,
but also with the greatest desire that the vow of celibacy will remain firm
and spotless, that it remain a source of sanctification for Catholic
priests, and never be an occasion of scandal and perversion.
There is shame because, inevitably, the abomination of a few will affect
the entire priesthood. Because of our solidarity, the crime of pedophilia
has harmed the reputation of priests all over the world. Similarly, the
holiness of priests lifts up the entire presbyterate. It is precisely this
solidarity which identifies Catholic priests, obliging us to share the
disrepute of the predators who wear the same clerical collar. We are
condemned and censured by public opinion as if we were guilty of the same
The news which was broadcast by the media bears a note of sadness for the
twofold scandal. First, there is the transgression of the Divine Law.
Secondly, we have to consider the hurt cast upon the candour and purity of
the victims, the poor children whom Jesus said are like angels who see the
face of God.
As He said, “it would be better for anyone who leads astray one of these
little ones who believe in Me to be drowned by a millstone around his neck
in the depths of the sea. What terrible things will come on the world
through scandal. It is inevitable that scandal should occur. Nonetheless,
woe to that man through whom scandal comes” (Mt. 18:5-9).
Jesus was adamant in reprimanding and avoiding scandals: “If your hand or
your foot is your undoing, cut it off and throw it from you! Better to enter
life maimed or crippled than be thrown with two hands and two feet into
endless fire. If your eye is your downfall, gouge it out and cast it from
you! Better to enter life with one eye than be thrown with both into fire.”
How can we remain models for our people in the face of these horrible
events? The only way to restore trust in the very field where some priests
have failed is by a strict exercise of our celibacy, because we priests are
called to emulate the chastity of our model, Jesus Christ. We try very hard
to imitate Him, so it would be seriously wrong to lose heart. The
overwhelming majority of us are generously dedicated to our ministry and
have the respect and love for our flocks which they deserve.
Looking at our parishes, at our gathering of the entire presbyterate, I
am amazed how faithfully, day after day, we serve the needs of the people
entrusted to our care. The criminal actions of a very few individual cases
are exploited by the media, as if the whole Church was corrupt and without
With dismay I listened to one young priest lament that perhaps we should
not wear our collars so no one would recognize us. He said: “People look
upon us as though we are monsters.” I replied, “Father, we must now, more
than ever, uphold the sign of our priesthood without shame. To be
discouraged and to withdraw from the public view is to surrender to Satan’s
“The more the media scrutinize the actions of priests who have abused
children, the more we must show that our conduct reflects the life of Jesus.
I also promise you that, after this ordeal is over, and it will be over
soon, the respect and our reputation will be restored.”
The best way to destroy mistrust is to show that our vocations are
genuine. Our parishioners appreciate our dedication. They love us. On the
other hand, the coverups, the permissiveness of the past, are ended.
In all dioceses, zero tolerance is now the rule. Perhaps the same
vigilance did not exist in the past; society preferred to hide the
molestations. Not any more. Our dignity will be respected and admired
because we are convinced of the sanctity of our priesthood.
Our priestly future, in this archdiocese, is strong and vibrant. The
presence of the Holy Spirit is moving our parishes. We are blessed with new
conversions and with those returning to religious practice. There is a
feeling among the faithful that our efforts, our prayers, our sacrifices are
the ladder they are taking for their spiritual life, to ascend to God.
Comment on the article above by
using this form...